Sara Heenan-Ross Public Discourse Blog
Saturday, June 3, 2017
End of class thoughts
I found it frustrating that not everyone seemed interested in sharing their thoughts. I thought we had an inviting environment that would be accepting of different opinions. I liked the day when we discussed the Rise of Enlightened Sexism because it was a discussion that everyone participated in and had really good opinions on. I enjoyed reading the Rise of Enlightened Sexism and Nobody. I think Nobody was an important read and made us aware of issues happening around our country today. I found the books more interesting than most of the articles with a few exceptions and the books seemed to generate better discussion. I enjoyed hearing from everyone this term. Good luck to everyone!
Tuesday, May 30, 2017
My research project for Legal/Ethical Issues in Higher Education
For my Legal/Ethical Issues in Higher Education I had to create a policy that I would want to have on a college campus. I chose to do my research on hate speech relating to college campuses. My goal was to create a policy that would ensure all students on campus feel welcome, safe, and not discriminated against individually or collectively. I was originally thinking that banning hate speakers from campus would be an easy solution but I quickly found out that trying to make a policy involving speech is very tricky. There is a very fine line between freedom of speech, hate speech, and hate crimes. Through my research I found that more speech,not less, seems to be a better solution. However, I still feel a campus should be a safe space for it's students. Hate speech has a domino effect on people's attitudes and actions. A guest speaker may come and go easily but the aftermath of their message stays on campus. In extreme cases students can become injured and college property can be damaged. This project ended up being rather frustrating in the sense that I really did not find a straight forward solution that would appeal to all.
My law classmates did help me come up with an idea that would allow students to be more involved in the selection of speakers who visit campus. They suggested that a panel of opposing and supporting students, of the guest speaker, sit down before the invite is given and discuss any concerns or hopes relating to the speaker. One other take away from this assignment that I learned was the importance of learning to listen to one another. To learn how to push away that feeling of needing to be right and be able to understand opposing views and why they exist in the first place.
My law classmates did help me come up with an idea that would allow students to be more involved in the selection of speakers who visit campus. They suggested that a panel of opposing and supporting students, of the guest speaker, sit down before the invite is given and discuss any concerns or hopes relating to the speaker. One other take away from this assignment that I learned was the importance of learning to listen to one another. To learn how to push away that feeling of needing to be right and be able to understand opposing views and why they exist in the first place.
Interesting Research Findings
Reading The Rise of Enlightened Sexism by Susan Douglas inspired the idea for my final project. For my final project I am researching one of my favorite TV shows from the 90's, Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman. The show first aired it's pilot episode in January of 1993. I have learned that it had 14 million households watching on the Saturday night prime time television slot. The show stared British actress Jane Seymour and many sites I have looked at call her the 'queen of the mini series'. She was well known before taking the lead on Dr. Quinn.
The show ran for six seasons and had a viewers of all ages watching, which is very uncommon. Most fans feel the show ended too soon and were surprised by the abrupt cancellation. It is unclear exactly why it was cancelled before nicely wrapping up the story. Supposedly ratings dropped,even though it continued to beat out rival shows and also cost production was an issue. However, several sources suggest that it was cancelled for featuring a female lead and not capturing the 'right' viewers.
The show was a Western but featured several things uncommon to most Westerns. "Unusual elements for a western included main characters who were African American, Native American, and ‘a female lead character, the central authority figure.” (Dow, p.165) When I was younger I never really stopped to appreciate the post feminist ideas featured on the show and it has been interesting to research now.
The show ran for six seasons and had a viewers of all ages watching, which is very uncommon. Most fans feel the show ended too soon and were surprised by the abrupt cancellation. It is unclear exactly why it was cancelled before nicely wrapping up the story. Supposedly ratings dropped,even though it continued to beat out rival shows and also cost production was an issue. However, several sources suggest that it was cancelled for featuring a female lead and not capturing the 'right' viewers.
The show was a Western but featured several things uncommon to most Westerns. "Unusual elements for a western included main characters who were African American, Native American, and ‘a female lead character, the central authority figure.” (Dow, p.165) When I was younger I never really stopped to appreciate the post feminist ideas featured on the show and it has been interesting to research now.
Saturday, May 27, 2017
Ms. Bev, My Dad, and trying my hand at poetry
Yesterday I went to visit my substitute grandmother Bev. She is turning 91 this summer. Ms. Bev is absolutely the most amazing and inspiring lady I have ever known. She is a true artist. For many decades Bev painted the most beautiful paintings of landscapes, animals, and cultural paintings. I’m honored to have her paintings hang in my house.
She loved to travel when she was younger and lived in Hollywood in her late teens / early twenties. While in California she met movie stars and sewed costumes for a film studios. Half her wardrobe is handmade and stunning. While out on an adventure, Bev met a drummer in a jazz band, George. The day George met Bev he said to a friend “That’s the gal I’m going to marry.” Three months later they got married with $15 dollars in the bank.
I didn’t know Bev till she was in her 60’s, we have a large age gap between us. I love spending time with her and hearing about her life. She’s been on many adventures. Yesterday, Bev was telling me how after she was no longer able to paint because of her arthritis that she tried her hand at poetry. She said “The Lord closed one door for me but opened another.” She shared some of her poetry with me that she wrote in the early 1980’s. It was simple, funny, and wonderful.
I’ve always wanted to be like Ms. Bev. I had red hair like her for most of my life. She finally let her hair go gray at age 88. I haven't mastered how to sew or paint but it’s on my to do list. I thought I would try my hand at poetry though.
As some of you already know, my Dad passed away this term. It has left a huge hole in my life and heart and has been a real struggle to keep going with day to day activities. I was very close with my Dad and he will forever be apart of me and who I am. I wrote some poems about how I’ve been feeling relating to the loss of my father and I wanted to share them on my blog. In the future I hope I can write happier poems in his memory.
A Happy Place
A happy place remains in my head
I can go there for a short while
I see his face and it smiles at me
His hand seems but just out of reach
His voice echos with words of wisdom
It is comforting and painful all at once
This place in my head will be my safe space
My escape from the void of a harsh reality
Absolute Stillness
I thrive surrounded by color
I bloom looking upon rainbows
My time to flourish has passed
The light has faded away
I’m alone in the dark
I wilt into the blackness
There’s a lack of color
A hole left in my heart
Strength
It’s very strange to try and be normal,
When the normal you knew is now gone.
Trying to move on and stay in the present is exhausting.
Everything is unfocused and hazy.
Trying to care seems pointless,
When what you cared most for is gone.
Yet, I keep moving
By some unknown strength I accomplish tasks
Goals are being completed.
Not just for me but for you,
My strength, my courage,
My Dad.
Finding My Way Back to Color
I know I will find my way back to the color.
You taught me better than to stay in the dark.
Lessons from the past will remain in the present.
The future will be colored by your lingering words.
Time has halted.
No, time just feels halted
Time doesn’t stay in a bottle
And I can’t go through time with you
Even if you’re the one I want most to go through time with.
Childhood doesn't last for eternity
But your love will, as will mine.
Friday, May 19, 2017
How should police practice be changed ?
I think improving the relationship between cops and young Black men would be essential to changing how the police practice and also improve the relationship between the community and the police officers. If it were up to me to make suggestions on how to improve these relationships I would make very simple, practical suggestions. First, I would suggest taking a look at the community at large. If the population of the community is made up predominantly of African Americans than I would say you need your police force to reflect this population. The police force should also be made up of individuals who are from the community and understand the difficulties of that area. I think police forces should evaluate the personalities and attitudes of the officers more carefully. If the officers are individuals who hold to negative stereotypes about people in their communities, than they are not the right person for that job. You can’t be policing justly and fairly with preconceived notions of your suspects.
After adjusting the police force I would attempt to repair the relationship between the community and the local police. Having the police get involved in the community as more of equals versus their normal authority status would be a good start. The police could hold a meet and greet at a community center. They could host town meetings to get dialogue flowing between them and community members. This would allow them to hear the expectations and needs of people in the community. I feel change is possible. It would probably be more complicated than I made it sound but still possible!
Monday, May 8, 2017
Gender Oppression
I feel like there have been many shows, fictional based, that try and represent having strong female characters. Game of Thrones has many women representing royalty and power. The Fall has a strong beautiful female detective leading murder investigations as does Law and Order SVU. 13 Reasons why has a young, smart, pretty teenager as a leading character. Bates Motel has a female who is slightly crazy, a single mom, and business owner. Even though these shows feature beautiful, strong women, they also feature a theme that represents how women are still the weaker sex. All of these tv shows show women being raped. These were recent shows that I could think of off the top of my head. I’m betting you all can think of even more shows on tv or movies where rape occurs on screen.
Sometimes when a show features women being raped they let the women get revenge to their rapist. Kill the man, chop off his man parts, or throw him in jail. Other times they show how the women's lives have changed or even come to an end as a result of the rape. There are still other times when a show will just move on with it’s plot like the rape scene was no big thing. In my opinion this last example is the worst.
I worry that when you show a rape scene and do not address properly, that it says this is an accepted part of our culture. I worry that the lack of respect shown to women on tv and in films will influence young males and their attitudes towards women. These are just fictional examples of how disrespecting women can influence viewers.
Even more threatening to our society is our President saying “when you are a star you can grab women by the pussy. You can do anything”. Not fictional and not acceptable.
Monday, May 1, 2017
Personal Finance
I came across an article posted by the Wall Street Journal titled ‘Should College Students Be Required to Take a Course in Personal Finance?’ The title instantly caught my attention and I found myself thinking Yes! As someone who has struggled financially, I can’t help but wonder that if I had taken a mandatory course focused on how to manage personal finances as an undergrad, perhaps I would be further along in my goals than I currently am today. Notice that I said mandatory course. I know the younger version of myself would never have signed up for a personal finance course unless it was a requirement. Personal finance has a serious scary tone to it that would surely involve math!
The article started by saying “Being knowledgeable about money management, budgeting and finance is no guarantee of success in life. But ignorance about such concepts often comes at great cost.” (WSJ) By not having all college students take courses in person finance universities are hindering the students chances of becoming successful financially. The article continued by saying that in 2015 the US was ranked 14th for it’s low financial literacy rate of 57% and that multiple studies have confirmed that college students do not understand how their student loans work. (WSJ) When college students graduate they are often starting out with tens of thousands of dollars worth of debt. Shouldn’t Universities be ensuring that their students know how to tackle paying off this debt without defaulting?
Knowing how financial instruments work is an important life skill. Wall Street Journal says that “Teaching personal finance is not about describing financial products, it is about teaching the principles of financial decision-making so that people understand how financial instruments work.” (WSJ) Knowing how to budget and understanding inflation are skills that will help people become financially stable. The article continued by saying that the lack of understanding has not just hurt people individually but collectively and this is a large contributing factor to our country's current economic state.
I found the questions that the Wall Street Journal was asking focusing on the future of current young adults very interesting and also a little disturbing.
“Looking ahead, will young people saddled with student loans be less likely to buy cars and homes? Will their ability to engage in transactions that require not just liquidity but good credit ratings be hampered? Will they veer away from starting their own businesses or pursuing advanced degrees? If they are not saving enough for retirement, will they have to be rescued from poverty in old age—and at what price to the country?” (WSJ)
These questions scare me because some of them have already come true and I want to prevent the end one from happening. I don’t want to have to be rescued from poverty. I want to possess the tools and knowledge to become financially successful. It’s not like I am even worried that I will never become rich, being rich has never been a goal for me. All I really want is to be able to support myself and my family at a comfortable level. Bills paid, food on the table, and presents under the Christmas tree. I have a feeling there are many other people that feel the same. I think financial stability would become more attainable for younger adults if their institutions insist on them taking a personal finance class while being an undergraduate. This class would provide life long tools and skills that could save many people from making irreversible financial mistakes.
Social Media Activism
What do you think about the role played by social media in contemporary social movements and activism?
I have mixed feelings on how useful social media can be when it comes to social activism. I feel that many people use social media to vent out their frustrations politically or otherwise. They can debate with “friends”, strangers, and share “news” posts to support their views. It can be draining to investigate who is posting true news and who is posting from non-credible sources. Most days Facebook makes me angry. I avoid it or I open Facebook and after two minutes I’m so annoyed that I close it and ask myself ‘why do I even look’?
Moving on… I do think that Facebook and other social media sites have helped form support groups and build online communities. As mentioned in the prompt, the Women’s March is a great example of how social media has contributed to mobilizing people. The massive amount of support from people who attended the March was a result of word spreading country wide. Without the use of social media the number of attendants would have been lower. I think social media will continue to help movements grow because of how fast information can be accessed online.
People may hear about an event through a weak connection, like the Women’s March, but when people take to the street and actively participate they create a strong, noticeable community with a louder voice. It's much easier to ignore a virtual movement than a protest with thousands of people.
Monday, April 24, 2017
Autonomous Future
Several times recently I have heard or read about the topic of driverless cars. Every time I hear this topic come up I wonder how this could possibly be real. I know that technology is constantly advancing but it makes me nervous to think that we rely on technology to do a task as important as driving a car.
As a society we have deemed that people must reach an age, sixteen, where they are responsible enough to understand all the consequences that come along with driving a car. Every time we get behind the driver's seat we have the responsibility to drive safely so that we do not harm ourselves or others on the road.
Cars that are able to take over this important task and self drive, lesson our awareness and need to be responsible. This is a new technology and I think it will take many accidents to prove that it is not safe or ethical. Should we even wait that long to decide? If the technology fails and the person in the car is unable to stop an accident from happening people may be seriously injured or even killed. Who’s fault would these accidents be?
Ultimately, we would blame the manufacturer for any design flaws or technology failures. What about the owners of the cars? They made the decision to purchase an autonomous vehicle that is meant to think for them and instead of them. Would they also share the blame?
The future of our roadways is heading towards driverless cars. It may be a long time away before the technology is ready to spread or not. The UK will have a driverless car trial on their motorways in the year 2019. BBC had an updated report.
“The Driven consortium is led by Oxbotica, which makes software for driverless vehicles. Founder Prof Paul Newman, of Oxford University, said: "We're moving from the singleton autonomous vehicle to fleets of autonomous vehicles - and what's interesting is what data the vehicles share with one another, when, and why."The project is backed by an £8.6m government grant and involves an insurance company, which will assess the risks involved at each stage of the journey.” (BBC)
These autonomous cars are also supported by science fiction writer Calum Chace. He was quoted in the BBC article about how he believes the driverless cars will make the roads safer and be more affordable. He said "I don't know why we have to wait until 2019," he said..."It will save so many lives and so much money." (BBC) People’s safety and financial cost or gain are very important factors to consider. If it proves to be overall safer and reduce accidents than it seems to make sense to make the switch to driverless cars. However, I still can’t accept that it won’t be flawless transition and can’t help but wonder who will get hurt when those flaws arise.
It sounds like autonomous cars will not be on the market till at least 2020 according to the guardian article “Twelve things you need to know about driverless cars.” The article also discusses how drivers will have the option to drive manually or let the car drive, allowing the driver to become a passenger and do other tasks such as preparing themselves for work. The Guardian article agrees with the BBC article that roadways will be safer. Stan Boland is a CEO for FiveAI and was quoted saying
“When you eliminate human error, our roads become dramatically safer: no more drink-driving, phone calls at the wheel, carelessness, inattention or plain bad driving. Clearly there needs to be adequate industry testing to ensure that AVs are safe for all other road users, but we can look forward to far safer roads as human drivers become a thing of the past.” (Guardian)
It sounds like safety is a priority, as it should be. However, I personally don’t think I would ever be comfortable being in an autonomous car, at least not one that would have to navigate through the Chicago-land volume of traffic.
Driverless Cars
My first topic for one of my op-eds focuses on driverless cars. I've read a few different articles on the subject and also heard this new technology mentioned on the news. Supposedly these driverless cars would be safer and eliminate road accidents. I just can't wrap my head around trusting a car to drive itself. It seems like a huge responsibility to be giving away to machines. I thought this op-ed assignment would be a good opportunity to read more in depth on the subject. The technology should be ready to be on the market for consumers between 2020-2025. In theory it sounds great, more free time to read or talk on the phone. But what about when the technology fails? Would you all want a driverless vehicle?
Thoughts on Polarization
Is polarization a bad thing? Are the cable news shows contributing to our current political polarization? What do I think? These questions are harder to answer than I expected. Our country has clearly felt more divided now than ever before in my lifetime. I don’t think polarization is always a bad thing but other times it can be. I don’t know what the correct answer is or even if there is one. From what I’ve read and seen lately I can say that the current political polarization feels negative.
I don’t think I would say that the news shows are persuading viewers so much as comforting them. I think viewers like to know that people share similar views as they do and that the cable shows are a visual representation of those political viewpoints. They are also a representation of the polarization but if you took away the cable shows the polarization would still exist.
I do think that the programs can help keep citizens interested in current events. It gives people topics of discussion and can also contribute to challenging views. You might not end up changing your mind on issues but can at least consider the other side's viewpoint. Maybe the cable shows do contribute to political polarization. I’m still stuck at being unsure.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
End of class thoughts
I found it frustrating that not everyone seemed interested in sharing their thoughts. I thought we had an inviting environment that would ...
-
Several times recently I have heard or read about the topic of driverless cars. Every time I hear this topic come up I wonder how this coul...
-
I feel like there have been many shows, fictional based, that try and represent having strong female characters. Game of Thrones has many w...